February 02, 2007

You said that there are arguments that atheists make that are as bad as the arguments that Christians make. Can you name some? I can't think of any.

There are, unfortunately, plenty of them. A few that seem to come up a lot:

  • Item X is the Bible is not literally true, therefore it is a mistake. (Add to this any argument about the Bible's content that does not take into account translation and the context in which it was written.)

  • Parts of the Bible are wrong, therefore all of the Bible is not true.

  • God couldn't make the earth stop turning to stop the sun in the sky because if he did then everyone would fly off.

  • Because he didn't have a father, Jesus would be a clone of Mary.

  • Religion is always harmful.

  • Christians do not follow their own teachings, therefore their teachings are wrong.

  • Religious people are stupid.

  • There is no evidence that God exists, therefore God doesn't exist.

  • God isn't omnipotent because he can't make a rock that he can't move. (Actually, an omnipotent being that is also perfectly moral could make a rock that it couldn't move.)


I'm sure more will come to mind as I think about this. And if any of my readers can think of more, please send them in!